Reply To not working correctly

I have the senders email address as the Reply to address but it is putting the form submissions are putting the site admin email address instead. How can I ensure that the Reply to address is email address the user entered?

I did search the forum, but the one most similar to my issue told them to open a new ticket, so that is what i am doing.

This is not a ticket, this is a public forum thread. So I recommend you to open a ticket, as we will need to ask you for some details that should remain private:

sorry, long week! Opening ticket now!