Notification not using selected field as "Reply-to"

I have a form with an input for an email address. When sending the notification I want to use that email field as the “Reply-To” address in the notification. Instead, the form uses my site’s general email address as the “Reply-To”. Here is my notification

What am I doing wrong?

Hi Brad. We would need to see the form and then log a submission on your site to see what Gravity Forms is doing and what happens after that.

Please first enable Gravity Forms logging:

Then test the form so it sends the notifications. Finally, open a support ticket here:
https://www.gravityforms.com/open-support-ticket/technical/

Be sure to include your system status report and an export of the form:

Thank you.

Submitted a ticket. Thanks!